Showing posts with label Race. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Race. Show all posts

Sunday, September 25, 2005

Hip Hop and America...

In response to my race and religion post, Shinsyotta directed me to a post he wrote entitled “Hip Hop’s Influence on Black Culture.” Utilizing an admitted fascination with memes (which I share), he draws a comparison between Hip Hop and religion. I too see the obvious correlations, and agree that musical genres and faith systems both play large roles in the development of an individual’s behaviors and personal preferences, and even influence political and social convictions. What I also note is that both are more specified (child) cultures within a larger, more general (parent) culture – in this case American culture. Influence traverses a two-way street in this system and, predictably, parental sway is more pronounced.

To this point, I believe I see the crux of what Shin is trying to convey, and am in general agreement. I can’t, though, allow Hip Hop to be a considered a cultural substitute for religion amongst blacks. They are two distinct forces with their own ramifications for each group. Religion does its damage and controlling for people of any race, ethnicity, color, etc. As I’ll demonstrate later, Hip Hop is just as powerful a force in white culture now as black. Overall, both have financially benefited whites more, and kept blacks in certain positions.

Hip Hop provides quite an interesting scenario, and I posit that its interrelation with the American system is cyclical and has come full circle. Its genesis lies in black experience; its impetus is American culture. With time, Hip Hop inevitably switched the tables and affected popular culture in America. This momentum was reversed, and the American way of life then took hold of the reigns. More simply stated – Hip Hop is a culture which arose in the black segment of America’s population in response to the conditions of America’s control on that segment, eventually grew to the point that it influenced popular culture in America, and, upon reaching that status, Hip Hop became an instrument to further those conditions of American control on that segment.

It’s all one big clusterfuck where America’s influence on black culture influenced Hip Hop which influenced America which influenced Hip Hop to influence black culture.

Still with me? Good.

First I want to point out that Hip Hop is not synonymous with black culture, and assuming so would be as ignorant as suggesting all white people wear John Deer hats, watch ‘rasslin’ and NASCAR, and have mullets. In Shin’s original he clearly states this with a disclaimer of generalization. Now, onto a quick clarification.

Rapping is something you do; Hip Hop is something you live. Hip Hop is much more than music. Those in the know state there are four elements of Hip Hop (with beatboxing occasionally thrown in as a fifth): DJing, MCing (rapping), B-Boying (breakdancing), and writing (graffiti art). These are merely forms of expression for Hip Hop as a full blown cultural phenomenon, and today we see that this definition of a system of parts seriously understates the complexity of the whole.

But music is the main channel through which a culture is expressed and spread (some may argue this prominence of music above literature and art, but I propose music is literature artistically presented – this, admittedly, is simplification to expedite my premise), and in our particular case, the music is undoubtedly the most visual aspect of this culture, so I will give focus to Hip Hop music as a generic for the culture.

Shin starts by stating that musicians, as pop culture icons, are in fact role models. I am in full agreement. As not only a Hip Hop head, but also an MC, I used to hate the idea of people allowing music to influence them. If true, my conscience would attempt to censor my artistic expression. I vehemently preached that the idea was utter bullshit. I was young, hopeful, and ignorant.

I live in a rather small city (pop. 40k) and witnessed a change in its black youth when BET and MTV finally arrived on our cable. Soon after, I was no longer the only white guy at the black parties and lunch tables.

Hip Hop definitely holds influence.

Jump ahead to 2005, and Hip Hop is now pop music and popular culture (as proud as I am, I am equally jealous and disappointed). The “mainstream” form we’re inundated with is that of common thuggery, misogyny, materialism, and general low class mentality.

And it is on purpose.

Music is a cultural phenomenon, and as such, it is a commodity. Music defines one’s choice of social grouping. Music is the litmus test of consumer interest and is intricately tied to demographics. Beyond being commercial, music and videos have become forms of commercials.

Historically, white America has created a certain image to be associated with black folk, and this is further pushed through the music.

I’m not saying that the record execs sit around plotting ways to keep blacks in a certain position, but that they shamelessly utilize pre-existing conditions to keep money in their pockets. Why change the ways of the world if they lead the way to your bank?

Notice that the music which is presented glorifies the assigned criminality and hedonism of blackness, which we (white people) find safe to emulate in our own skin (I don’t have room here to postulate why we find black folk so inherently “cool” and “hip.”), and the commercial use is still manifest shuckin’-n-jivin’ and skinnin’-n-grinnin’. Entertainment is a type of service, and whites have never had a problem with what blacks can do for us – it’s what they can do to us that terrifies (and motivates) us.

White teenage boys would not be (and weren't) rushing to the stores en masse to buy Paris, X Clan, or Public Enemy or Talib Kweli and Immortal Technique. That voice doesn’t portray the image of blackness they’re familiar with, and therefore isn’t “genuine” enough to be marketable. Educated and socially conscious? Please! The news doesn’t show black graduates and entrepreneurs, it shows composite police sketches of suspects. Blacks graduate from the streets (school of hard knocks) and black entrepreneurs are drug dealers and hustlers (and now record execs). Likewise, little teenybopper white girls want to dance, be the desired sexual objects portrayed in the music, and see Ja Rule and 50 with their shirts off.

A sad result is a proportion of the black youth running around with bandanas hanging out of their pockets (thanks to Snoop, at least they're on the correct sides, but this only provides further emphasis – a profound example indeed) and belittling one another for not wearing as much (African slave) jewelry and being equal victims of capitalist oppression and materialist superficiality. There’s an influx of individuals who don’t own property but have four-figure-dollar rims on their cars; buying hundred-dollar sneakers instead of paying tuition.

It may be argued that Hip Hop has drastically improved race relations in America. Today’s white youth are much more likely to associate with black youth and be aware of some of the issues that face these fellow Americans. Interracial relationships are much more prevalent. White kids idolize black men, something unheard of in their parents’ generation. As legendary MC KRS One puts it, “what go around come around I figure: Now we got white kids callin' themselves ‘niggas’.”

But look a little deeper. Most white guys who are “down” don’t emulate KRS. Their mold isn’t Cornel West, Michael Eric Dyson, Tavis Smiley, or even John H. Johnson or Martin Luther King, Jr. – eloquent, conscious, educated bothers. They idolize 50 Cent and Young Jeezy. They put on their “blackcent” and emphasize how “hard” they are. They perpetuate images of poverty, ignorance, violence, and criminality. Liekwise, white girls don’t aspire to be Oprah, Shirley Ann Jackson, Toni Morrison, Maya Angelou or myriad other positive, strong sisters. It’s Lil’ Kim’s lofty status they aspire to, and they continue myth’s of promiscuity and animal-like sexual drive and prowess (while carnal excellence and gifted endowment may possibly perceived as positive for black men, a look into these myths’ origins quickly present an ugly truth).

And more and more black kids are doing the same.

Shin touches on this by presenting the underachievement speculation:

“Anyone who succeeds and grows as a person is seen to be abandoning the culture and as somehow less ‘black’.”

This is a frequently voiced situation, which I’ll admit does have some value, though it is hardly exclusive. It is human nature to need belonging and to define what merits it accordingly. “Misery loves company” is a truism. Nearly all lower class and economically challenged people exhibit apparent underachieving qualities and engage in ostensibly self-sabotaging activities in the face of seemingly insurmountable obstacles. It provides comfort, and can be seen as choice instead of submission or defeat. It is perceived as a reclamation of sorts to take what is perpetuated against you and use it to define yourself.

Shin also believes that black society’s exclusive “blackness” is ultimately negative for an inclusive society to flourish. This is a more tricky issue.

I disagree that a “separate ‘black culture’ is detrimental to human society.” I hold it is the complete opposite – variety is the spice of life. The only alternative is assimilation, which has historically proven disastrous. Conformity of cultures translates to a loss of identity. A separate black population is detrimental (perhaps this is what he meant). It is not the separation of black culture but its place in overall American [read: white] culture that impedes human society.

His statement, that as a result, “they therefore…don't contribute to human society as a whole” is quite dangerous territory. I think I see where he’s coming from and what he’s getting at, and I offer that individual and categorical differences define, not defeat, human society.

All in all, for lack of better term, everything's not black and white. Hip Hop, its roots planted in black culture, has become American and, increasingly, world culture. This has had definite positive impact, but its long-term effects aren’t proving to be completely constructive, or even benign. What we see manifested is a conditioned, socially engineered, self-fulfilling prophecy of sorts. Hip Hop presents an increasingly complex paradox and reflection of the fires that provided the spark of its creation. Sadly, it has defeated itself through its own success.

Friday, September 23, 2005

The American Culture of Race and Religion...

In response to my post(s) on race and religion, Aaron Kinney (for whom I have a high amount of respect) commented:

"I think it’s cultural rather than racial, personally."

As he clearly states, this is his personal opinion – to which he is completely entitled, and along with which I very frequently find myself in total agreement (still undecided as to objective vs relative morality). Quite obviously, this is one of those rare times I disagree. While a simple conflict of opinion is very minor indeed, I feel this particular statement deserves further consideration.

For clarification, "cultural" needs to be defined before this point can be considered (all emphasis mine):

"cul·ture (kŭl'chər)
n.
1. The totality of socially transmitted behavior patterns, arts, beliefs, institutions, and all other products of human work and thought."

This is a very broad, sweeping definition, and includes religion as a mere piece of a larger puzzle.

"2. These patterns, traits, and products considered as the expression of a particular period, class, community, or population: Edwardian culture; Japanese culture; the culture of poverty."

This, I feel, is more along the lines of what AK meant, but it would apply more to the African American culture as a whole, which is multi-faceted, and of which religion is only a part, no matter how big a part.

"3. These patterns, traits, and products considered with respect to a particular category, such as a field, subject, or mode of expression: religious culture in the Middle Ages; musical culture; oral culture."

This would narrow it down to what the topic is: religious culture amongst Americans, and its differences amongst blacks and whites in particular.

"4. The predominating attitudes and behavior that characterize the functioning of a group or organization."

I think this is more along the lines of 1.2 above.

If AK intended "cultural" along the lines of 2 (and 4), it just isn't particular enough.

I personally feel that some people use words like "culture" to dampen the effect when they mean "race." In fact, when it all boils down, the modern, Western concept of race is a purely social construct with no scientific validity. It can be argued (valiantly and biologically) that there is only one race - human, or Homo sapien sapiens - with an overwhelming body of supporting evidence from geneticists. From there we see that what we refer to as races are in fact just separate cultures - or, more specifically, population groupings - within that one race, essentially based on geographic separations. But we have to be real here: those different categorical groupings would be divided along pretty much the exact same lines we currently use to popularly define race. Obviously, there are distinct cultural differences between, and amongst, the races - which, by the way, allow for some flexibility (me for example) - but the similarities, although emphasized far less, outweigh the differences.

Besides, that's not what I was getting at in my post.

Due to the way history has played out we find ourselves in the current predicament: We live in a country that's overwhelmingly Christian, and divided along color lines. This is and has been a fact since non-indigenous (read: European) people first arrived, complete with cargoholds for stolen goods, resources, and lives, aspirations of colonialization and imperialism, a capacity for mass genocide and land theft, and a Bible full of atrocities to back it all up.

In my post, I feel I focused on issues that were blatantly based on, and particular to, race (in its most widely understood connotation). The curse of Canaan is based on a perceived literal translation of Noah's sons' names, specifically that Ham actually meant "black" (a priori or not). It has been accepted for years that Noah's sons we're the precursors of today's racial divisions. Canaan (Ham's son)'s curse to be a servant amongst servants (the word "servant" is used in translation throughout the Bible where the intent is no less than "slave") to the other two for all time was a major defense used by white people for enslavement of Africans.

The history of Europe's people cannot be told without tales of conquest, colonizing, and empire building or with the exclusion of Christianity. Through the first, the second was spread (whilst the second was used as the excuse for the first). Another consequence of conquest was the subsequent subjugation of the conquered by the conquerors (how's that for alliteration).

{My current personal theory is that Europe's relatively small size and lack of resources made expansion a must, and conquest a necessary evil. Both Africa and the Americas' sheer size and natural abundance provide explanation for the relative absence of these actions on each respective continent. I cannot accept that blacks and Native Americans were too ignorant or unambitious to engage in near constant war and colonization of other people's land, nor that Europeans have an innate bloodlust and greed (although for the latter it does seem to be a cultural norm). Geography of course played a major role, but I am digressing from the point at hand.}

I need not hear that white slavery was a reality or that freed blacks also held slaves, as it is essentially meaningless. It cannot be argued that the black experience in America has been anything other than one of oppression – property for over 300 years, then merely three-fifths of a (hu)man, and nothing less than a second-class citizen since. This is not debatable. The Civil Rights era was only 40 years ago. White Americans as a whole have held a position of (absolute, crushing) power from the very arrival of Europeans in 1492 (here I need not be informed that the Irish and other European immigrants were mistreated - or that pre-Columbus explorers reached the continent).

I illustrated that this relationship of subjugator and subjugated formed distinctly different views on, needs for, and practices of religion in America.

Here, culture is irrelevant. An elderly black man in Mississippi and a teenaged black girl in the Bronx (or Beverly Hills for that matter) can be, and probably are, as different as possible culturally, yet share the same legacy and most likely the same religious views. The mere fact that Christianity can be found on six continents, in nearly every nation, and amongst people of completely different backgrounds – one-third of the earth’s population – demonstrates that it is a culture all to itself which transcends and further distinguishes other cultures completely.

I fail to see how the psychological damage of a slave mentality, or the perceived and realized privilege of a master mentality, as they apply to religion, and as religion applies to them, are cultural issues.

Although, as I acknowledged, there are certain similarities on socio-economic (class) levels, there is still a major difference. A difference that gets to the heart of matters of race in America, and which is the only discernable, distinguishing characteristic of a "white culture" in America...

No matter how poor or socially excluded a white person is, they can always say, "at least I’m not black."

Atheists in an increasingly Christian dominated society should – albeit to a very, very small degree – be able to relate, or at least sympathize.

Thursday, September 22, 2005

Shooting Myself In the Foot...

I pen an entry that, although I won't say is an absolute must read, is deserving of consideration, and it goes unnoticed. Well, at the least, unremarked. I really, truly thought this particular piece would be my most read to date, and would inspire serious commenting.

I then, in the mood to focus on something much more lighthearted and inconsequential, post a movie critic-styled entry that drips of self-indulgence, focusing on a couple of compliments I received recently. This gets comments.

I'm disappointed, but not surprised.

It doesn't require a perusal of my entire blog to see that I have an affinity for discussing two topics in particular: race and religion. Those near and dear to me are all too aware of this (and I fear a bit annoyed). I pretty much only discuss items considered controversial by the lethargically apathetic masses. Why waste time opining the already well established? Well, I fucked around and wrote one post focusing on the two combined, and it may have bit me in the ass.

I am fully aware that the heavy emphasis on both endangers readership. Why? Well, we know I wouldn't bite my tongue in a seizure, so I'll call it like I see it.

I suppose it safe to assume the individuals who will gravitate toward one subject matter over the other most likely have a vested interest in the particular issue they choose. This seems rather obvious. I'll wager that those choosing race are either a representative of a minority, an individual who comes in frequent contact with such or, conversely, a racist of sorts. Likewise, those partaking of the religious commentary are most likely either atheist, the "undecided" in search of answers, or theists actively looking for debate.

Basically, I’m suggesting black folk are peeping my race posts and atheists are here for the god-bashing.

At the risk of perpetuating a form of stereotyping (imagine that) I have to note that, from my own observations, African Americans are less likely to be agnostic or atheist, and therefore don't share my views on religion (I would love to see actual data on this). On the other hand, I suspect most of the faithless visitors are white, and, although overwhelmingly liberal-minded freethinkers, have natural aversions (future topic) to my posts on racism.

Boy that was a lot of stereotyping.

The bottom line? I fear the people who would frequent more often to read my essays on discrimination may be turned off by my overtly anti-Christian themed posts, and vice versa.

What's noteworthy is that both groups are in the minority nationally, discriminated against by the same common enemy, and outspoken (bravely so) about issues of major importance, yet choose their comfort zones according to what most affects them on an individual basis. Maybe this is closed-minded. Maybe it just makes sense and is efficient. Maybe I just want someone to read my dammit post and tell me what they think.

I’ll note here that the issues of race and secularism are two of the most important we face, and the two most debated during the founding years of this country. See how far we’ve come in 230 odd years?

Saturday, September 17, 2005

The Race to God (Part 3)...

*This is part three of a three part post. The three parts are meant to be continuous, as opposed to being a related series, and should be read as such. The post was broken down into separate parts for ease of presentation and commenting.*

The OT is ripe with tales of evil-doing, untrustworthy outsiders and the strict precautions and violent measures that have to be taken with respect to such. I need not outline Israel’s gruesome, barbaric conquest and eradication of outside nations, committed in the name of their god’s jealousy, insecurity, and general malevolence.

More particularly, the tales of Cain (Gen. 4:15) and Ham/Canaan’s (Gen. 9:20-27) curses have serious repercussions for black people. Some may argue that the popularly held beliefs about these verses are misconceptions, but this is a moot point, as these connotations are just that – popular, specifically so during the era’s in which we saw their implications materialized on a grand, heinous scale.

Aside from the above quoted verses, the Bible has many passages which promote homogeneity, push heritage and blood-lines, and support genocide and slavery. A precursory investigation into the history of slavery, segregation, and anti-miscegenation in America, and especially the justification thereof, is awash with religion. It should also be noted that most racist groups in the US identify themselves as Christian (KKK, WCOTC, Christian Identity, et al.). These bigots often quote the Bible as divine justification for their ideology (eg. Genesis 1:24-25; Numbers 25:7,8; Ezra 10:3; Acts 17:26-27).

Add Biblical support for slavery, orders against “mixing,” and a curse that doomed black people to be the ultimate “servants” to the already established notion of original sin (read: inherent worthlessness) and Jesus’ “turn-the-cheek” policy of acquiescence, and the apple pie-and-baseball-American tradition of racism isn’t exactly a bewildering situation.

Christianity is also completely devoid of any sensible concept of justice. In fact, two of its major premises completely contradict and counteract each other:

The concept of original sin states, in essence, that punishment for crimes committed by one can be imposed on others.

Jesus’ death tells us that the punishment of one person can be used as retribution for all other’s crimes.

For those who believe in salvation by faith (as opposed to works), a child-molesting murderer who accepts Jesus has more right in Heaven than an altruistic philanthropist who doesn’t. The Christian emphasis on forgiveness further demonstrates that someone can do pretty much anything and ultimately get away with it.

The picture painted is that god favors one group of people over another, doesn’t want people mixing it up too much (to the point of ordered, justified, and assisted genocide), doomed black folk to a position of inferiority and servitude, decides culpability and retribution are essentially capricious, enforces complaisant obedience, and rewards pretty much anyone, no matter how they lived, a one-way ticket to paradise – as long as they believe it without question, regardless of evidence.

This is why the oppressed can seek comeuppance through the exact same faith that the oppressors use to avoid their own. The very same god avenges and recompenses the downtrodden and advocates and exonerates the despot.

And on Sunday, a black preacher will deliver a sermon that the gods created man in their image, and orders "thou shalt not judge", and "love thy neighbor" to a congregation of black faces, while across the street a white pastor preaches the same to pews full of white faces.

The Race to God (Part 2)...

*This is part two of a three part post. The three parts are meant to be continuous, as opposed to being a related series, and should be read as such. The post was broken down into separate parts for ease of presentation and commenting.*

It’s not hard to imagine a victim of a system of discrimination and subjugation having thoughts such as: Why the oppression? What evil has been committed to excuse this? What have I done to deserve this?

Well, easy...

For one, man is completely depraved and born in original sin. You are inherently broken, and barely worthy of creation and life without an intermediary to sacrifice on your behalf. A SUPREME proxy at that, so what makes your mere mortal form worthy of pardon? If God’s beloved son – HIMSELF even! – must endure such an unspeakable and unjust hardship for YOU, then how dare you complain!! So little is asked of you in return, and such great and magnificent promise awaits those appreciative and righteous enough to accept – and be thankful for – it.

Add in virtuous portrayals of humility, suffering, and pacifism, a divine example of forgiveness to aspire to, and the New Testament’s thick sense of rooting for the underdog.

All told, you’re informed of your innate worthlessness, instructed to take whatever’s handed out, and promised a final, absolute compensation. Mix in liberal amounts of fear, and you have the ultimate recipe for pacification.

This isn’t specific to racial minorities – we see evidence of this in the inverse relationship between religious convictions and social status – but it is especially pertinent: a pertinence that is compounded when the Old Testament is brought into play.

Part Three »

The Race to God (Part 1)...

*This series of posts represents the melding of what may be the two most prevalent topics of conversation in my day to day life – two topics that are also deemed mutually inappropriate to speak about. Oddly, this is possibly the first time I’ve focused solely on this combination unto itself, and as such I do not expect the thoughts put forth here to be conclusive or exhaustive. As an American citizen, I’ll mainly address Christianity. As an American citizen, I’ll mainly address race in black and white. As neither black nor Christian, this may even be conjecture and speculation, but beyond being merely opinion, it is my perspective – one that might not be quite as “on the outside looking in” as it may seem on the surface.*

There is no denying the connection between race and religion. The most basic observation is that each “revealed” religion was geographically specific to a particular ethnic group or “nation.” The fact that the revelation was bestowed upon this select group usually implied some sort of divine appointment. As for claims of superiority, what more needs to be said if the creator(s) entrust(s) you alone with the rules to the game?

While this may not necessarily apply to race (or its popular connotation) in particular, it does apply to an exclusive group, which starts the ball rolling.

One must also take into account the chronological context of these belief systems’ conceptions. This is a time in which the concept of societies– large groups of humans living together –interacting with other societies and building a global society is a burgeoning experiment (a condition that may still be valid). This is a time in which “others” are out to get what you’ve claimed (ditto). This is a time to stick to your own – a time of extreme xenophobia.

But what happens as religions spread outside and beyond their original boundaries? What implications do they carry with them for people who are the very outsiders that, by the religion itself, those who were “chosen” were originally separated from? I first seriously pondered this when discussing the Christian treatment of death, which is quite appropriate, because few conditions of humanity are so closely tied to religion as death.

Many of the funerals I've been to were for young black men. These funerals achieve more in the aim of rejoicing the departed’s “crossing over” than mourning his life. Here's where I'll mix politics with religion. In a social context which suffers a disproportionate amount of tragedy, the religion's message of hope is much more, well, hopeful. Raised on the religion given to their ancestors (slaves) so they'd behave, faith's power to pacify is second nature. Living a legacy of injustices, the message of later redemption is particularly strong.

Of course, once brought into perspective, this makes adherence to the faith that much more contradictory and maddening, but it can also provide some explanations.

People who live a life of privilege merely see an eternal afterlife as an extension of sorts, minus some annoying nuisances.

People caught in a struggle see it as a release – a final end to misery and actual reward. Just the very thought of the possibility of such an existence is a respite in itself.

The latter is remarkably similar to the Jews who formed the religion. The former is reminiscent of the Romans (and later Church) using it to control power.

Let's just think of some of the things that come to mind when we think of wide-scale white Christian-based events: Crusades, Inquisitions, Dark ages, witch hunts, genocides, etc. For those who may want to pick, I'll limit it to American history: witch hunts, genocides, slavery, misogyny, segregation, discrimination...

Compare that with the only (to my recollection) Christian-based event led by American blacks on a massive scale - the Civil Rights era protests.

From this we see how multi-faceted the religion is, and how it can be contorted to conform to the needs of the "believer," and the way the religion is viewed and used by its respective followers.

The subjugated see the message of peace and retribution. The subjugators latch onto the xenophobia and themes of God-willed supremacy. Hope vs justification, or, more specifically, Hope (and how it’s justified) vs (hope for) Justification.

Part Two »